SOVA-blog

Between Paris and Kakheti: The Triumph and Exile of the “Georgian Caruso”

In 1924, a scandal erupted at the Paris Grand Opéra. The lead tenor flatly refused to perform before the Soviet ambassador. The audience did not have to guess at his motives for long: the celebrated French artist of Georgian descent explained his decision directly from the stage.

Picture the scene: the early 1920s, and Carmen is being staged at the Grand Opéra. The audience is comfortably settled in the auditorium, and among them, seated in the diplomatic box, is the Soviet ambassador to France—a representative of the regime that had just brutally and bloodily crushed the August Uprising in Georgia.

Suddenly, the lead performer steps out before the curtain. Turning toward the diplomatic box, he addresses the entire hall in French:

“I am a son of little Georgia. Most of you do not even know what a great culture belongs to my homeland, where at this very moment people fighting for freedom are being slaughtered. Seated here is a representative of the country that committed this atrocity. And as long as this man remains in the hall, I will not sing!”

The auditorium erupts. Uproar, whistles, shouts. Bowing to public pressure, the Soviet diplomat makes a humiliating exit from the opera house. Only then does the tenor take the stage to thunderous applause. France knew this fearless tenor as Michel Dariali. But his real name was Mikheil Nanobashvili, and his story began far from the French capital—in Georgia’s Kakheti region.

Nanobashvili was born in Telavi, his family originated from the village of Vakiri, and from childhood he sang in a church choir in Tbilisi. Did he dream of Europe’s premier opera houses back then? Hardly. At first, the young man traveled to Saint Petersburg and enrolled in the faculty of law.

However, a rare, deep, and velvety lyric-dramatic tenor voice completely altered his life’s trajectory. Jurisprudence was left behind, and Mikheil entered the conservatory. There, his vocal training was overseen by one of the Russian Empire’s foremost authorities, Professor Stanislav Gabel. Yet the Saint Petersburg school alone was not enough for him: Nanobashvili moved to Milan, where he brought his Italian vocal technique to perfection.

In 1908, the young man from Kakheti stepped onto the stage of the Paris Grand Opéra for the first time. It was then that he adopted the stage name Dariali—in honor of the Darial Gorge. To him, those mountains symbolized both a border and the enduring image of the homeland he had left behind.

That debut was followed by resounding international acclaim. Dariali played to packed houses across Canada, Spain, Italy, Turkey, and Azerbaijan. His portrayals of Raoul in Les Huguenots and Don José in Carmen drew praise from the entire European press, with critics dubbing him the “Georgian Caruso” for the extraordinary power and velvety timbre of his voice. Even the legendary Vano Sarajishvili, hearing him in Tbilisi, shouted “Vasha, Michel!” (“Bravo, Michel!”) from the audience and openly acknowledged that Dariali surpassed many global stars.

Yet his relationship with his native Georgian stage took a tragic turn. Mikheil attempted to return home twice—in 1911 and 1920. He wanted to live and sing for his people. However, the bureaucracy and administration of the Tbilisi Opera House met him with a cold refusal, claiming there were no positions available for him.

Nanobashvili returned to France with deep bitterness and heartache. Only to turn Europe’s premier theatrical stage into a political platform in 1924, openly denouncing the Soviet regime for the annexation of Georgia.

Mikheil Nanobashvili spent the rest of his life in exile. He lived in Paris, continued to sing Georgian songs at diaspora gatherings, and passed away in September 1941, during the Nazi occupation of France. He was laid to rest in Paris’s renowned Montmartre Cemetery.

During the Soviet era, authorities attempted to erase his name and consign it to oblivion. Yet Dariali’s protest at the Grand Opéra remains etched in history—as a testament to the fact that stripping a country of its freedom is often far easier than breaking the spirit of a person devoted to their homeland.

Support freedom of speech in Georgia

SOVA — is an independent voice covering events in the region in Russian. In a time of pressure on the media, your support guarantees our independence and ability to tell the truth.

You may also like

More in SOVA-blog